Comments on: Harry Potter Horcrux Redux

By: Anonymous

Anonymous — Thu, 21 Jun 2007 18:08:28 +0000

The horcruxes are
1. Tom Riddles Diary (destroyed)
2. Tom Marvolo Riddle’s ring (destroyed)
3. (Slytherin) The locket (destroyed by R.A.B?)
4. (Hufflepuff) The cup
5. (Ravenclaw) The mirror of Erised
6. (Gryffindor) Possibly Harry himself.
7. Voldemort himself obviously

You see, I agree with all the statements that Harry is a horcrux but this doesn’t nesescerily mean he’ll die. I think Harry is a horcrux because remember when he was being sorted into his house and the Sorting Hat wanted to put him in Slytherin. Harry should have gone in Slytherin because of his personality but I think the reason the Sorting Hat put him in Gryffindor was because Gryffindor didn’t have a horcrux and all the other houses had. After all, there was no other main reason why Harry was in Gryffindor anyway. And J.K did state at some point that it was very important why Harry was in Gryffindor.
Good theory?

By: Chenturan

Chenturan — Sat, 20 May 2006 08:08:34 +0000

it is commmented by dumbledore “that the order can cover up deaths” when he is speaking to malfoy
i just dont think that dumbledore would have so much faith in a person and be killed by them

By: Richard

Richard — Sat, 20 May 2006 02:20:44 +0000

theres no point for snape to kill dumbledore to keep his cover. he killed dumbledore and the order of the phoenix wont trust him ever again, even if it is true that dumbledore told snape to kill him the order never new so they wont believe snape. so there wont be any point in spying if he cant tell the order what voldemorts going to do

By: Richard

Richard — Mon, 15 May 2006 01:28:47 +0000

marge in the 6th book when harry and dumbledore r in slughorns real memory, he tells tom riddle that there is a spell that you need to use to make a horcrux. so voldemort couldnt have made harry a horcrux because when he tried killing harry with the avada kedavra curse it back fired and went on him ripping him form his body to where he couldnt use a wand so theres know way he could have made harry a horcrux.

and has anyone thought that harry could still talk to dumbledore? remember at the end of the 6th book when harry and mcgonagle walk down to dubmledores office he had a picture on the wall behind the chair. harry could go and talk to dumbeldoe about the horcruxes.

i think that snape will die. i think that harry will catch up with him and snape will try and wiggle himself out of with excuses but harry will be covered in to much hatred and kill him and follow on after voldemort

By: Chenturan

Chenturan — Fri, 28 Apr 2006 05:00:29 +0000

Look guys
harry being a horcrux is not a twist…its obvious…too obvious
im sure rowling knows that lots of people r gonna think he is so she is gonna suprise make us all look like idiots. In addition, if rowling planned on harry being horcrux after seein the hundreds of site that people r thinking this she will have no choice but to change this.

She purposely puts in little things to make us think about stuff like this i.e the small mentioning of regulus black….harry finds the initial r.a.b

As for snape… dumbledore isnt stupid, he has continuously said that snape is a gud guy…dumbledore was gonna die anyway…so snape killed him to keep his cover.

By: Paul

Paul — Mon, 28 Nov 2005 00:11:38 +0000

oh my goodness! i only realized this after watching the fourth movie!

assuming snape is a good guy, he should be able to use priori encantatem to talk to dumbledore just as voldemorts wand showed harry his parents, cedric, etc.

also, was a horcrux necisary to provide voldemort with the portion of his soul he has starting in book 1?

By: Paul

Paul — Mon, 28 Nov 2005 00:11:11 +0000

oh my goodness i only realized this after watching the fourth movie!

assuming snape is a good guy, he should be able to use priori encantatem to talk to dumbledore just as voldemorts wand showed harry his parents, cedric, etc.

also, was a horcrux necisary to provide voldemort with the portion of his soul he has starting in book 1?

By: Seth

Seth — Mon, 19 Sep 2005 15:01:43 +0000

Aaron, this is an intriguing idea. I’d love to hear more. Blog it and ping this post to keep the discussion going.

Better yet, join bloggingharrypotter.com and blog it there!

By: Aaron

Aaron — Sun, 18 Sep 2005 04:25:14 +0000

I dont think Harry himself is a horcrux but his scar is. And remember J.K. Rowling said the last word of book seven is scar. I think they will cut the scar out of his head. What do you think?

By: Nat

Nat — Sun, 11 Sep 2005 17:08:17 +0000

Harry Potter # 6 Theories

RAB- Regulus A(rmadillo) Black

Horcruxes- 1) Tom Riddle’s Diary
2) Tom Morvolo’s Ring
3) Slytherin’s Locket
4) Hufflepuff’s Cup
5) Something of Ravenclaw
6) Nagini or Harry Potter?

1) Diary already rid of in book 2
2) Ring already rid of by Dumbledore
3) Locket may be rid of by “R.A.B”
4) The cup still at large
5) Ravenclaw’s wand??
6) Nagini the snake or Harry Potter could be a horcrux himself (also, Harry could be considered a Gryffindor horcrux)

Harry Potter Horcrux- Why would Voldemort try to kill Harry if he was a Horcrux?
-When has he ever really tried to kill him?

Book # 1: We find out that he tried to kill Harry but the spell backfired giving him the scar, etc. Maybe he was really trying to make Harry a Horcrux.
Clues: “Lily needn’t have died…” because James was murder enough to create a horcrux.
Book # 2: It was the diary that fought Harry. It was the Tom Riddle from 50 years prior; therefore that Tom Riddle didn’t know that Harry was a horcrux.
Book # 3: Voldemort does not attempt to murder Harry in this book either…the only thing that happens is Wormtail rejoins his master.
Book # 4: Voldemort needs Harry’s blood to regain a body. On the contrary of killing Harry, he tells the death eaters not to harm him. He specifically wants Harry’s blood even though he can use anyone’s because Harry may have a part of his soul in him. Also, he gains the protection from Harry’s blood.
Book # 5: At the ministry Voldemort tells all the death eaters not to harm Harry…” He is for Voldemort”. Also, when Dumbledore and Voldemort are having the battle, Voldemort enters Harry’s body and says to Dumbledore “Kill me now” therefore killing Harry too, but Dumbledore doesn’t do it. Voldemort did not kill Harry.
Book # 6: Once again, death eaters are given orders not to harm Harry.

Alchemy- Black/White/Red
Sirius/Albus/Hagrid ???

Elements: 1) Fire 1) Sword
2) Earth 2) Pentacle/Disc (locket??)
3) Air/Wind 3) Wand 4) Water 4) Cup

1) Gryffindor
2) Slytherin
3) Ravenclaw
4) Hufflepuff

Fire- courage, moral backbone, passion, doing what is right (Gryffindor)
Earth- power, money, having power in whatever you set out to do (Slytherin)
Air- intellect, logic, doing what is logical and truthful (Ravenclaw)
Water- Love, Care, nurture, healing… (Hufflepuff)

Snape- -Good guy
-Killed Dumbledore on Dumbledore’s orders
Clue: The conversation Hagrid overhears between Snape and Dumbledore in the Forbidden Forest (book 6).
-Will help Harry in the end

Malfoy- -Will be protected by the Order of the Phoenix